Friday, December 11, 2015

Has the GOP Shrunk to its Tribalist Core?

The Republican party is too insular--so say party leaders themselves. Or, as GOP leader and head of the American Conservative Union put it, "Our party needs to realize that it's too old and too white and too male and it needs to figure out how to catch up with the demographics of the country before it's too late."

In the 2012 presidential election, Romney had bested Obama handily in the white demographic, with 59 percent of European-Americans voting for the Republican nominee. Nearly nine in ten of Romney voters in 2012 were white. No GOP had had attracted more white voters since Reagan routed Mondale in a 49-state sweep back in 1984.


Nonetheless, Obama still won re-election by a comfortable 4 percentage points.

The numbers tell the story: Obama was able to overcome his historic 18 point deficit among white voters because he enjoyed a 58 percent lead among minority voters. In fact, Obama garnered overwhelming support from every significant minority group (including fully 93 percent African-Americans, 71 percent of Hispanic-Americans, and 73 percent of Asian-Americans).

The reality for the GOP—which is well-understood by party establishment types—is that the party is increasingly dependent on the white vote. Minority Republican voters make a disappearingly small share of the Republican base. The problem: the share of all-important white voters in the United States is fast shrinking (from a high of 89 percent in 1976 to 72 percent in 2012).

This means, as noted by GOP strategist Karl Rove,  that the party will need to win increasingly lopsided election sweeps of white voters (along the order of Reagan’s 1984 victory over Mondale) to remain competitive in presidential races, and that "It's unreasonable to expect Republicans to routinely pull numbers that last occurred in a 49-state sweep.”

In fact, according to recent estimates, the GOP would need to win at least 64 percent of the white vote, and 30 percent of the non-white vote in order to win the presidency in 2016. (The last time the GOP broke the 60 percent ceiling on the white vote was in the 1980s, and the proportion of non-white voters supporting the GOP comes nowhere near to 30 percent.)

GOP leaders are well aware of the coming demographic crisis and proposed strategies for reversing its losses in its official “autopsy” report of the 2012 election loss.  The aim was to figure out how to expand the GOP's appeal, particularly to minority communities. Said the report in part,

"...among the steps Republicans take in the Hispanic community and beyond, must be to embrace and champion comprehensive immigration reform," the report read. "If we do not, our Party's appeal will continue to shrink to its core constituencies only."

What are those “core constituencies”? In a word (or five): white, Southern, male, rural, older.

A former GOP Congressman characterized the losses as follows: “Politics has been defined by culture over the last few cycles, and we’ve become a rural party and a Southern party. We’ve been losing inner suburbs and the like.”

To escape this bind,  GOP strategists reckoned that Republicans would need to pass some form of immigration reform to appeal to the Hispanic community, which is disproportionately harmed by the US's byzantine immigration system. And at the very minimum, Republican politicians needed to stop race-baiting. The logic followed that if the GOP could shake their image as hostile to minorities, then social conservatives within the Hispanic and black communities might well come over to the GOP.
  
Fast Forward Three Years

The 2016 presidential election is still 11 months out, but it is already clear that the GOP, far from moving toward a larger tent, has pitched—so to speak—the smallest pup tent imaginable.  Why? Because the tribalist core of the GOP hates “inclusivity” and “outreach,” particularly to minority communities. And the tribalist core is increasingly in the drivers seat. In short, the Republican Party has nowhere else to go.

For months, real estate mogul and reality television star, Donald J. Trump, has enjoyed a commanding lead in the polls, thanks largely to the support of these core groups. The chart below, created through Huffpost Pollster, illustrates shifts in popular support for all GOP contenders from June to December:




The most notable feature of the Trump candidacy (apart from the fact that the candidate has never held public office) is his unapologetic nativism and America-Firsterism. Trump launched his bid by painting a picture of an insecure U.S.-Mexican border openly flouted by a tide of illegal aliens who are “rapists,” “murderers,” “bringing drugs and crime.”  The solution announced Trump, is constructing a “big beautiful wall” that Mexico would pay for. Trump later expanded on his plan with a “deportation force” that could go door to door to round up and expel undocumented individuals.

Trump does not so much ignore minority communities in his campaign speeches, interviews and debate appearances as much as he openly antagonizes them--in order to pander to the GOP’s “core constituencies.” Rather than a dog whistle, Trump favors a blowhorn.

Until the ISIS attacks in in Paris, Trump started nearly every campaign appearance with some statement about America needing to “win” again (against China, Iran, Japan…) and how he would build an awesome wall to keep Mexican undesirables out.

After the Paris attacks, Trump pivoted neatly from Mexicans to Muslims, proclaiming (among other things) that the US not take in any Syrian refugees, for fear that some might be terrorists. When asked, he said he favored a database for keeping track of Muslims in America (a suggestion he has since walked back to some extent). And of course, Trump would “hit ISIS” and “hit them hard,” even "taking out their families." In the wake of the workplace shootings by two Muslims in San Bernardino, Trump advocated banning Muslims from entering the United States as either tourists or immigrants until the government "can figure out what's going on."

Trump’s raw, unfiltered tribalism resonate powerfully with much of the GOP base. This much is clear from popular reactions to Trump’s campaign events, focus groups, and opinion polls. Other Republican candidates are following Trump’s xenophobic lead. Why? Because that is where the GOP’s “core constituencies” are taking them.

According to a Public Policy Poll conducted in August, as many as 63 percent of Republican voters want to amend the Constitution to eliminate birthright citizenship. A Bloomberg Politics poll revealed that 65 percent of likely GOP primary voters favor banning Muslims from traveling to the US, and a Rasmussen Report revealed that 70 percent of likely Republican voters support building a wall to keep Mexicans out of the United States. Finally, a CNN/ORC poll shows that 63 percent of Republicans favor mass deportation of undocumented individuals (against 29 percent of Democrats).

Trump's positions, far from extreme, are right in line with those of the GOP base.

Seeing Trump’s success with the GOP tribalist core, nearly every GOP candidate has made some effort to appeal to the base. One-time fellow frontrunner, Ben Carson, declared he would seal the US-Mexican border within a year of assuming office, and within six months registering and eventually deporting undocumented individuals;  Marco Rubio favors shutting down mosques and any place where Muslims could gather to be inspired by extremism. Even supposedly moderate GOP presidential contender John Kasich proposed establishing a federal agency to promote “Judeo-Christian” values. Jeb Bush, too, attempted to revive his status as the party’s presumptive nominee—suggesting that the U.S. only let in Syrian refugees who can prove they are Christians

What Next for the GOP?

The GOP establishment is frankly "in chaos" about where this would leave the party, or even the country. According to the Washington Post, one Republican strategist said:

 “We’re potentially careening down this road of nominating somebody who frankly isn’t fit to be president in terms of the basic ability and temperament to do the job. It’s not just that it could be somebody Hillary could destroy electorally, but what if Hillary hits a banana peel and this person becomes president?”

When Frank Luntz conducted a focus group of Trump supporters back in August, his supporters made it clear that there was nothing anyone could say to shake their confidence in Trump, particularly when coming from members of the Republican establishment. Luntz was most stunned by evidence that Trump's supporters seemed unshakable in their enthusiasm for the frontrunner, even negative ads highlighting Trump's lies or distortions. Luntz said later, "This is real. I'm having trouble processing it. Like, my legs are shaking,"

The chickens have finally come home to roost for the GOP—decades after Nixon’s Southern Strategy and the infamous Willie Horton ad that sank Michael Dukakis in 1988. The fatal decision by the GOP to use race-baiting pick up southern votes a generation ago left the party with a shrinking electoral base that may now be too small to win presidential races. For its part, the base resists the very makeover that will save the party itself.

29 comments:

  1. Great piece Erin. No surprises except how scary it is when you line it all up like that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Rhodri...synthesizing is my forte :)

      Delete
  2. An excellent information provided thanks for all the information i must say great efforts made by you. thanks a lot for all the information you provided.please visit:Packers And Movers Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  3. Lovely Website, Maintain the fantastic work. Thank you so much!
    Local Packers and Movers Ahmedabad list, Cheap Packers Movers Ahmedabad Charges, Affordable, Best Household Shifting Ahmedabad @ Packers and Movers Ahmedabad

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for sharing.please visit here for more detail:

    Packers and Movers Bangalore

    ReplyDelete
  5. Fancy designer wear our website and reasonable price More…
    We Have Some For You In Your Budget For more…
    Plz visit:- Wedding Dresses


    ReplyDelete
  6. Meaningful information, thanking you for sharing. I will visit…. again
    Memorial Day Sayings
    Memorial Day Quotes Photos

    ReplyDelete
  7. Awesome information, Thanks for sharing. I will come again…………….
    Memorial Day 2017 Images
    Memorial Day Quotes for Loved Ones

    ReplyDelete
  8. Best Outfits For Young ladies,Womens and Girls
    We Have Some For You In Your Budget For more…
    Plz visit:- Salwar Suit

    ReplyDelete
  9. Exclusive Collection of Salwar Suit and Many More…
    We Have Some For You In Your Budget For more…
    Plz visit:- Designer Anarkali Salwar Kameez

    ReplyDelete

  10. Designer Anakali Dresses is perhaps the desire of every single girl in this world to look amazing on her wedding day.
    It is certainly important that the bride must be the star of the show.The most beautiful woman at the wedding venue.
    In India,Anakali Dresses are the most obvious choice for the brides.There are many Anakali Dresses in our site...
    For more...
    Plz visit:- Anakali Dresses

    ReplyDelete
  11. an awesome blog thanks a lot for giving me this great opportunity to write on this.please visit our website I assure you that it will be very useful for you
    Packers And Movers Jaipur

    ReplyDelete
  12. Our Collection is Best Designer Saree Lehenga, Gown ,Salwar Kameez etc...
    For more...
    Kurti
    Designer Kurti
    Wedding Dresss
    Punjabi Suit
    Diwali,Christmas,New year for Collection....
    Happy Diwali
    Merry Christmas
    Happy New Year Images

    ReplyDelete
  13. The most beautiful woman at the venue.
    In India Kurtis is are the most obvious choice for the brides.There are many designer Kurtis in our site...
    We have New Massive Collection For Here....
    Pakistani Dress
    Designer Sarees
    Wedding Lehenga
    Salwar Kameez
    Salwar Suit
    Anarkali Suit
    Anarkali Dress
    Kurtis
    Wedding Dress
    Punjabi Suits

    ReplyDelete
  14. An adorable personality partnered with a perfect choice for Designer Dress unbeatable.
    Even before the blossom of modernization in Indian culture, kurta, sarees, and salwar kameez had been part of India's unique civilization.
    In India,Designer Salwar Kameez are the most obvious choice for the Young Ladies & Girls.There are many Designer Salwar Kameez in our site...
    Punjabi Dress
    Wedding Saree
    Lehenga Choli
    Ghagra Choli
    Silk Saree
    Ladie Suit
    Indian Saree
    Designer Dress
    Brindal Dresses
    Designer Kurtis

    ReplyDelete
  15. Have Lovely and Beautiful Salwar Suit Saree, Gown And Many More…
    We Have Some For You In Your Budget For more…
    Plz visit:
    Lehenga
    Saree
    Gown
    Brindal Lehenga
    Pakistani Dress
    Designer Saree
    Wedding Lehenga
    Salwar Kameez
    Salwar Suit
    Anarkali Suit

    ReplyDelete
  16. Fancy designer wear like that saree,salwar suit,Kurtis our website and reasonable price More…
    We Have Some For You In Your Budget For more…
    Anarkali Dress
    Punjabi Dress
    Wedding Saree
    Lehenga Choli
    Ghagra Choli
    Silk Saree
    Ladies Suit
    Indian Saree
    Designer Dress
    Brindal Dress

    ReplyDelete
  17. A movie is used for an entertainment of busy people.
    By seeing movie person experiences refreshment from their day to day life.
    For watching movie plz visit following site:-
    kingsman: the golden circle full movie download kickass torrent
    kingsman: the golden circle full movie the piratebay

    ReplyDelete
  18. Christmas is one of the time where people do shopping a lot and ask the question Christmas and new year wishes thankyou so much for useful content. great job.. keep going.

    ReplyDelete